Listen Live

Study reveals that many people prefer a "Mean Boss" instead of a "Nice Boss"

Published July 16, 2025
By MJ
Mr Spacely/ The Jetsons via Hanna-Barbera

When it comes to bosses, who would you prefer? Michael Scott from "The Office?"

Or Miranda Priestly from "The Devil Wears Prada"?

It turns out, the answer isn't obvious.

A study suggests that many people would prefer a mean boss over a people pleaser.

Not everyone finds the soft touch a good thing when it comes to management; it just depends on how you view the world.

A study conducted by Columbia Business School suggests that people who believe the world is "dog-eat-dog" are more likely to respect and admire abrasive, forceful managers. AKA- a mean boss.

However, if you think the world is more collaborative, your view of the tough-as-nails management style is ineffective and unbearable.

The study was inspired by a workplace incident a few years ago involving the manager of an Olive Garden who sent a scathing memo to employees after too many people called in sick.

The memo stated, "If you call off, you might as well go out and look for another job.”  And “If your dog died, you need to bring him in and PROVE it.”

While people thought his reaction was harsh, many applauded his technique and no-nonsense approach.

The study summarizes that for some, toughness signals savvy leadership. For others, it’s just poor management, doomed to fail.

Feature image from The Jetsons via Hanna-Barbera

What do you think of this article?
+1
0
+1
0
+1
0
+1
0
+1
0
Advertisement

Live and amplified

Plug yourself in to the best classic rock and hottest new rock
Listen Live
Advertisement
Advertisement

Snag Our Newsletter

Hit that button like you’re pressing play on your favourite track. get exclusive content, stories, and news.

Subscription Form

Related

Advertisement
Advertisement

Upcoming Concerts

Advertisement
Advertisement

Latest Podcasts